Vehicle Service Experts Best Practice: Coaching

 Back to Resource Hub
Vehicle Service Experts Logo

Is Coaching Worth It for Your Shop? Here’s How to Tell

Disclaimer: The Vehicle Service Experts Resource Hub shares resources, insights, and industry experiences contributed by independent shop owners serving on the Vehicle Service Experts Council of the Auto Care Association (“Association”). The Association offers the information, materials, and resources provided on this page for general informational and educational purposes only. The Association makes no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of any information contained herein. Nothing on this resource page constitutes legal, financial, tax, technical, or professional advice. Accessing or relying on such third-party resources is done at your own risk and the Association disclaims all liability for any loss or damage, including without limitation indirect or consequential loss or damage, arising out of or in connection with the use of, or reliance on, this resource page or any materials provided herein. Use of this resource page constitutes acceptance of this disclaimer.

Know Why You’re Hiring a Coach (Before You Hire One)

The most successful coaching relationships start with clarity.

Best Practice: Identify the problem you’re trying to solve

  • You’re working too many hours
  • Growth has stalled
  • Team accountability is inconsistent
  • Financials look “okay” but not strong
  • You feel stuck or isolated as an owner

Choose a Coach Who Understands the Auto Repair Business

General business coaches can help — but industry-specific knowledge accelerates results.

Best Practice - Look for a coach who understands:

  • Flat rate vs. hourly realities;
  • Technician shortages;
  • Advisor/tech tension;
  • Parts margins and labor efficiency;
  • The emotional toll of shop ownership;
  • Hiring difficulty; and
  • Knowing your “numbers”.

Questions to Ask a Coach

  • “How many repair shops do you currently coach?”
  • “What does success look like for shops like mine?”
  • “How do you hold owners accountable?”

Involve the Right People — But Not Everyone

Not all coaching is meant to be shared immediately.

Best Practice - Decide early

  • What stays at the ownership level?
  • What gets cascaded to leadership?
  • What becomes team-facing later?

Tip

Many shops see faster improvement when:

  • Owners are coached first;
  • Advisors and managers follow later; and
  • Technicians benefit indirectly through better leadership

Coaching Is Not About Fixing the Shop — It’s About Fixing the Owner First

A coach doesn’t magically fix systems. They help the leader change how the business is run.

Best Practice: Be open to examining:

  • Your decision-making habits;
  • How you communicate expectations;
  • Where you avoid confrontation; and
  • What you personally refuse to let go of.

Reality Check

  • If you’re not willing to change, coaching will feel frustrating.
  • Growth almost always starts with discomfort.

Coaching Works Best When You Commit Fully (Time, Data and Honesty)

Partial commitment leads to partial results.

Best Practice

  • Show up prepared for every session
  • Share real numbers, not guesses
  • Be honest about what isn’t working
  • Execute between sessions

Expectation Setting

  • Coaching is not passive
  • If you treat it like a class, you’ll get class-level results
  • If you treat it like a partnership, results compound

Additional Resources

* Auto Care Association or Vehicle Service Experts are not affiliated, sponsored or promoting any specific groups. Listed groups are for reference only.

For Questions

Missy Stephens
Missy Stephens
Community Engagement Manager

missy.stephens@autocare.org

 

(240) 333-1072